Everyone seems to be talking about AI these days. Yet most companies still struggle to say where they stand. That is where an AI maturity model comes in handy. It gives you a simple way to measure progress. It also shows you what to fix next. So, instead of guessing, you get a map. In this post, we will walk through what these models measure, why scores are slipping, and how to move up a level without burning out your team.
What an AI Maturity Model Measures
Most maturity frameworks follow the same basic idea. First, they describe a series of stages. Then, they score your organization against each one. The early stages usually involve curiosity and small experiments. Later stages involve AI running inside core processes every single day.
However, the stages are only half the story. Good frameworks also look at several dimensions at once. For example, the Enterprise AI Maturity Index from ServiceNow and Oxford Economics surveyed nearly 4,500 executives and scored them across five key dimensions (ServiceNow & Oxford Economics, 2025). As a result, a company can look strong in one area and weak in another. That nuance matters. After all, a slick chatbot means very little if your data is a mess.
In short, think of the framework as a health checkup. It does not judge you. Instead, it points to the next thing worth your attention.
Why Maturity Scores Are Dropping
Here is the surprising part. You might expect scores to climb every year. Instead, the opposite happened recently. The average maturity score in the ServiceNow index fell nine points, from 44 to 35 (ServiceNow & Oxford Economics, 2025). That is a big slide in just one year.
So what happened? Simply put, the target moved. New tools such as AI agents arrived quickly. Consequently, companies that felt mature a year earlier suddenly had new gaps to close. The bar went up faster than most teams could climb.
Meanwhile, other research tells a similar story. McKinsey found that 88 percent of organizations now use AI in at least one business function (McKinsey & Company, 2025). Even so, most remain stuck in experimentation or piloting. Likewise, Deloitte reports that only 25 percent of organizations have moved 40 percent or more of their AI experiments into production (Deloitte AI Institute, 2026).
In other words, adoption is wide but shallow. Nearly everyone has started. Far fewer have scaled.
The Typical Stages of Growth
Although every AI maturity model uses its own labels, most share a familiar arc. First comes an exploring stage. People test tools on their own. Leaders watch from the sidelines. Next comes a piloting stage. Here, a few teams run formal experiments with clear goals.
After that, companies reach an operational stage. At this point, AI supports daily workflows, and someone owns the results. Finally, there is a transformational stage. In this stage, AI changes how the business creates value, not just how fast it works.
Notably, most companies stall in the jump from piloting to operations. Pilots are cheap and fun. Production is harder. It needs clean data, clear owners, and steady funding. Therefore, many organizations collect pilots like souvenirs and never scale any of them.
Using an AI Maturity Model to Plan Your Next Move
So how do you turn a score into action? First, be realistic about where you are. Ask simple questions. How many use cases run in production today? Who gets the call when one breaks? Those answers say more than any slide deck.
Second, pick one dimension to improve this quarter. For instance, if governance is weak, start there. Deloitte found that only 21 percent of companies have a mature governance model for autonomous agents (Deloitte AI Institute, 2026). Clearly, that gap is worth closing before agents spread.
Third, focus on strategy, not just tools. BCG reports that companies with a clear AI strategy see 25 percentage points more impact from AI than companies without one (Boston Consulting Group, 2026).
Finally, revisit your score every six months. The technology keeps moving. Consequently, your map needs regular updates too.
What Pacesetters Do Differently
Of course, some companies are pulling ahead. ServiceNow calls them Pacesetters. Interestingly, 83 percent of Pacesetters report higher gross margins than 64 percent of other companies (ServiceNow & Oxford Economics, 2025). Moreover, about two-thirds of them run their AI on one platform with a single data model.
That detail is worth pausing on. A unified foundation makes it easier to add new tools later. In contrast, scattered systems create friction at every step.
Similarly, McKinsey’s high performers are far more likely to have scaled AI agents than everyone else (McKinsey & Company, 2025). Their leaders also tend to champion AI openly. As a result, the effort feels like a company priority rather than a side project.
Wrapping Up
To sum up, an AI maturity model is less about grading and more about direction. It shows where you stand. It also shows the very next step. Scores may dip as the technology races ahead, and that is okay. What matters is steady movement. So, start small, fix one gap at a time, and keep checking your map. Before long, you will notice the progress adding up.
References
Boston Consulting Group. (2026). AI at work: Why strategy matters more than tools. https://www.bcg.com/publications/2026/ai-at-work-why-strategy-matters-more-than-tools
Deloitte AI Institute. (2026). The state of AI in the enterprise: The untapped edge. Deloitte. https://www.deloitte.com/us/en/what-we-do/capabilities/applied-artificial-intelligence/content/state-of-ai-in-the-enterprise.html
McKinsey & Company. (2025). The state of AI in 2025: Agents, innovation, and transformation. https://www.mckinsey.com/capabilities/quantumblack/our-insights/the-state-of-ai
ServiceNow & Oxford Economics. (2025). Enterprise AI maturity index 2025. ServiceNow. https://www.servicenow.com/workflow/ai/enterprise-ai-maturity-index-2025.html


